Method of estimation of radiation risks of mortality among Chernobyl clean-up workers with consideration to probable errors in cause-of-death reporting on death certificate

«Radiation and Risk», 2023, vol. 32, No. 2, pp.22-33

DOI: 10.21870/0131-3878-2023-32-2-22-33

Authors

Chekin S.Yu. – Head of Lab. Contacts: 4 Korolyov str., Obninsk, Kaluga region, Russia, 249035. Tel.: (484) 399-30-79; e-mail: This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it. .
Maksioutov M.A. – Head of Dep., C. Sc., Tech.
Karpenko S.V. – Engineer
Tumanov K.А. – Head of Lab., C. Sc., Biol.
Korelo A.M. – Sen. Researcher
Shchukina N.V. – Sen. Researcher
Kashcheeva P.V. – Sen. Researcher, C. Sc., Biol.
Zelenskaya N.S. – Researcher
Lashkova O.E. – Researcher
Ivanov V.K. – Scientific Advisor of NRER, Chairman of RSCRP, Corr. Member of RAS, D. Sc., Tech. A. Tsyb MRRC.
A. Tsyb MRRC, Obninsk

Abstract

In the past decade the lawful use of radiation risks of non-cancer diseases estimates to solve radiation safety problems has become more significant. The highest statistical power of low dose (less than 0.2 Gy) radiation risks research is possible in the cohort of the Chernobyl clean-up workers (liquidators) registered and been under medical monitoring in the system of the National Radiation Epidemiological Register (NRER) since 1986. The liquidators total number exceeds 130 thousand people. Because of the large-scale annual collection of health data, carried out in the NRER system, verification of the diseases diagnoses and medically certified causes of death, a natural question of radiation risk estimates compatibility with consideration to probable errors in a disease diagnosis and cause-of-death reporting on death certificates arises. The work is aimed at estimating the radiation risk of mortality from diseases of the circulatory system and diseases of the digestive organs in the Russian cohort of liquidators, with account of possible errors in the disease diagnosis and certified causes of death. The size of the cohort considered for mortality analysis was 91,013 people, the average age at the Chernobyl zone entry was 33.6 years, average radiation dose was 0.133 Gy. In this study, the method of maximizing the partial likelihood function was used to assess radiation risks, with consideration of individual radiation doses to liquidators and the assessment of background mortality using the Breslow method. The specificity of the diagnosis of the primary causes of death in the NRER system significantly exceeds the level of 0.99. Considering the specificity index of 0.99, the estimates of radiation risk coefficients ERR/Gy for mortality from diseases of the circulatory system and diseases of the digestive system in the cohort of Russian liquidators do not differ from the estimates obtained in the assumption that there are no first kind errors (false positive diagnosis) in the diagnoses of the primary causes of death in the NRER database. The results obtained confirm the high stability and validity of the assessments of radiation risks of mortality from diseases of the circulatory system and diseases of the digestive system, obtained earlier from the data on liquidators registered in the NRER.

Key words
radiation risk, excess relative risk, mortality, errors in coding causes of death, bias in radiation risk assessment, Chernobyl clean-up workers (liquidators), external gamma exposure, absorbed dose, diseases of the circulatory system, diseases of the digestive system.

References

1. Preston D.L., Ron E., Tokuoka S., Funamoto S., Nishi N., Soda M., Mabuchi K., Kodama K. Solid cancer incidence in atomic bomb survivors: 1958-1998. Radiat. Res., 2007, vol. 168, no. 1, pp. 1-64.

2. Jablon S., Ishida M., Beebe G.W. Studies of the mortality of A-bomb survivors. 2. Mortality in selections I and II, 1950-1959. Radiat. Res., 1964, vol. 21, pp. 423-445.

3. Belsky J.L., Tachikawa K., Jablon S. The health of atomic bomb survivors: a decade of examinations in a fixed population. Yale J. Biol. Med., 1973, vol. 46, no. 4, pp. 284-296.

4. Shimizu Y., Kato H., Schull W. J., Hoel D.G. Studies of the mortality of A-bomb survivors. 9. Mortality, 1950-1985: Part 3. Noncancer mortality based on the revised doses (DS86). Radiat. Res., 1992, vol. 130, no. 2, pp. 249-266.

5. United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR). Effects of ionizing radiation. UNSCEAR 2006 Report to the General Assembly with Scientific Annexes. Vol. II. New York, United Nations, 2009. 338 p. Available at: https://www.unscear.org/docs/publications/2006/ UNSCEAR_2006_Report_Vol.II.pdf (Accessed 30.05.2023).

6. ICRP, 2007. The 2007 Recommendations of the International Commission on Radiological Protection. ICRP Publication 103. Ann. ICRP, 2007, vol. 37, no. 2-4, pp. 1-332.

7. Medical radiological consequences of Chernobyl: forecast and actual data after 30 years. Eds.: Corr. Member of RAS V.K. Ivanov, Corr. Member of RAS A.D. Kaprin. Moscow, GEOS, 2015. 450 p. (In Russian).

8. Pitkevich V.A., Ivanov V.K., Tsyb A.F., Maksyutov M.A., Matyash V.A., Shchukina N.V. Dosimetric data of the All-Russia Medical and Dosimetric State Registry for emergency workers. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 1995, special issue 2, pp. 3-44. (In Russian).

9. United Nations Scientific Committee on the Effects of Atomic Radiation (UNSCEAR). Effects of ionizing radiation. UNSCEAR 2006 Report to the General Assembly with Scientific Annexes. Vol. I. New York, United Nations, 2008. 392 p. Available at: https://www.unscear.org/docs/publications/2006/ UNSCEAR_2006_Report_Vol.I.pdf (Accessed 30.05.2023).

10. Ivanov V.K., Maksioutov M.A., Chekin S.Yu., Kruglova Z.G., Petrov A.V., Tsyb A.F. Radiation-epidemio-logical analysis of incidence of non-cancer diseases among the Chernobyl liquidators. Health Phys., 2000, vol. 78, no. 5, pp. 495-501.

11. Ivanov V.K., Maksioutov M.A., Chekin S.Yu., Petrov A.V., Biryukov A.P., Kruglova Z.G., Matyash V.A., Tsyb A.F., Manton K.G., Kravchenko J.S. The risk of radiation-induced cerebrovascular disease in Cherno-byl emergency workers. Health Phys., 2006, vol. 90, no. 3, pp. 199-207.

12. Ivanov V.K., Chekin S.Yu., Kashcheev V.V., Maksioutov M.A., Tumanov K.A., Tsyb A.F. Mortality of the Chernobyl emergency workers: dose dependences and groups of the potential risk. Radiatsionnaya biologiya. Radioekologiya – Radiation Biology. Radioecology, 2011, vol. 51, no. 1, pp. 41-48. (In Russian).

13. Ivanov V.K., Kashcheev V.V., Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Tumanov K.A., Kochergina E.V., Shchukina N.V., Tsyb A.F. Morbidity and mortality among emergency workers of the Chernobyl accident: assessment of radiation risks for the follow-up period of 1992-2008. Radiatsionnaya gygiena – Radiation Hygiene, 2011, vol. 4, no. 2, pp. 40-49. (In Russian).

14. Little M.P., Azizova T.V., Bazyka D., Bouffler S.D., Cardis E., Chekin S., Chumak V.V., Cucinotta F.A., de Vathaire F., Hall P., Harrison J.D., Hildebrandt G., Ivanov V., Kashcheev V.V., Klymenko S.V., Kreuzer M., Laurent O., Ozasa K., Schneider T., Tapio S., Taylor A.M., Tzoulaki I., Vandoolaeghe W.L., Wakeford R., Zablotska L.B., Zhang W., Lipshultz S.E. Systematic review and meta-analysis of circulatory disease from exposure to low-level ionizing radiation and estimates of potential population mortality risks. Environ. Health Perspect., 2012, vol. 120, no. 11, pp. 1503-1511.

15. Kashcheev V.V., Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Tumanov K.A., Menyaylo A.N., Kochergina E.V., Kashcheeva P.V., Gorsky A.I., Shchukina N.V., Karpenko S.V., Ivanov V.K. Radiation-epidemiological study of cerebrovascular diseases in the cohort of Russian recovery operation workers of the Chernobyl acci-dent. Health Phys., 2016, vol. 111, no. 2, pp. 192-197.

16. Kashcheev V.V., Chekin S.Yu., Karpenko S.V., Maksioutov M.A., Menyaylo A.N., Tumanov K.A., Kocher-gina E.V., Kashcheeva P.V., Gorsky A.I., Shchukina N.V., Lovachev S.S., Vlasov O.K., Ivanov V.K. Radia-tion risk of cardiovascular diseases in the cohort of Russian emergency workers of the Chernobyl accident. Health Phys., 2017, vol. 113, no. 1, pp. 23-29.

17. Ivanov V.K., Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Kashcheev V.V., Karpenko S.V., Tumanov K.A., Korelo A.M., Kochergina E.V., Vlasov O.K., Shchukina N.V., Lovachev S.S. Radiation risk of incidence of hypertensia among Russian recovery operation workers of the Chernobyl accident. Meditsinskaya radiologiya i radiatsion-naya bezopasnost – Medical Radiology and Radiation Safety, 2017, vol. 62, no. 1, pp. 32-37. (In Russian).

18. Breslow N., Day N. Statistical methods in cancer research. Volume II. The design and analysis of cohort studies. IARC Scientific Publication No. 82. Lyon, IARC, 1987. 406 p.

19. International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health, 10th revision (ICD-10). Vol. 1 (Part 1). Geneva, WHO, 1995. 698 p. (In Russian).

20. International Statistical Classification of Diseases and Related Health, 10th revision (ICD-10). Vol. 1 (Part 2). Geneva, WHO, 1995. 633 p. (In Russian).

21. Gorski A.I., Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Shchukina N.V., Kochergina E.V., Zelenskaya N.S., Lashkova O.E. Method for assessing the radiation risks of the solid cancer incidence accounting for possible diagnostic errors. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2022, vol. 31, no. 4, pp. 53-63. (In Russian).

22. Breslow N., Day N. Statistical methods in cancer research. Volume I. The analysis of case-control studies. IARC Scientific Publication No. 32. Lyon, IARC, 1980. 350 p.

23. Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Kashcheev V.V., Karpenko S.V., Tumanov K.A., Kochergina E.V., Zelenskaya N.S., Lashkova O.E. Estimating of radiation risks of non-cancer diseases among Russian Cher-nobyl cleanup workers. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2021, vol. 30, no. 1, pp. 78-93. (In Russian).

24. Preston D.L., Lubin J.H., Pierce D.A. EPICURE User's Guide. Seattle, Hirosoft International Corp., 1993. 330 p.

25. Breslow N.E. Discussion of the paper by D.R. Cox. J. R. Statist. Soc. B, 1972, vol. 34, pp. 216-217.

26. Chekin S.Yu., Maksioutov M.A., Kashcheev V.V., Karpenko S.V., Tumanov K.A., Korelo A.M., Kochergina E.V., Zelenskaya N.S., Lashkova O.E., Shchukina N.V., Ivanov V.K. The influence of dose uncertainty on the assessment of radiation risks of non-cancer mortality among Russian participants in the liquidation of the consequences of the accident at the Chernobyl nuclear power plant. Radiatsiya i risk – Radiation and Risk, 2022, vol. 31, no. 2, pp. 21-35. (In Russian).

Full-text article (in Russian)